Understanding Testamentary Spousal Trusts: Benefits, Drawbacks, and Estate Planning Tips

Learn how testamentary spousal trusts provide income for your spouse, protect family wealth, and offer key tax benefits in estate planning

What is a Testamentary Spousal Trust?

A testamentary spousal trust is an estate planning tool established through a will to ensure financial support for a surviving spouse while protecting the capital for future beneficiaries, such as children. It is particularly useful in situations where the testator (the person who creates the will) wants to provide for their spouse but also preserve the assets, like a family business or other valuable property, for heirs after the spouse’s death. This type of trust offers both financial security for the surviving spouse and protection for the family’s wealth.

How Does a Testamentary Spousal Trust Work?

Upon the death of the testator, certain assets are transferred to the spousal trust rather than being given outright to the surviving spouse. The spouse is then entitled to receive all the income generated by those assets for their lifetime, while the capital (the assets themselves) is preserved within the trust. The trustee manages the trust, ensuring that the assets continue to generate income for the spouse while safeguarding the capital for eventual distribution to the children or other named beneficiaries after the spouse passes away.

A testamentary spousal trust offers several tax advantages, including the deferral of capital gains tax on assets transferred to the trust. The tax on capital gains is deferred until the surviving spouse dies or when the trust assets are sold, allowing the family to preserve more wealth over time.

When to Use a Testamentary Spousal Trust

This type of trust is particularly beneficial in situations such as:

• Blended Families: When the testator wants to ensure that their spouse is supported but ultimately wants the assets to pass to children from a previous marriage.
• Wealth Protection: For families with significant assets, like a family business or large investment portfolios, a spousal trust can prevent the capital from being accessed or depleted by the surviving spouse, ensuring it passes to the next generation.
• Business Succession: If the testator owns a business, a spousal trust can allow the spouse to benefit from the income generated by the business while ensuring the business is eventually passed to the children or other heirs.

The Benefits of a Testamentary Spousal Trust

There are several benefits to using a testamentary spousal trust in an estate plan:

1. Tax Deferral: One of the main advantages is the deferral of capital gains tax. Upon death, assets transferred into the trust are not subject to immediate taxation. Instead, the tax is deferred until the surviving spouse dies or the trust assets are sold. This helps to preserve more of the estate’s value.
2. Income for the Spouse: The surviving spouse is guaranteed to receive income generated by the trust’s assets for life, providing them with financial stability without having direct access to or control over the capital.
3. Capital Protection: The trust protects the capital (such as shares of a family business or real estate), ensuring that it is passed on to children or other beneficiaries after the spouse’s death. This protection ensures that the family’s wealth is preserved.
4. Creditor Protection: Assets in a testamentary spousal trust are typically protected from the surviving spouse’s creditors. This means that even if the spouse faces financial difficulties, the assets in the trust remain secure and intact for the future beneficiaries.
5. Professional Management: The assets within the trust can be managed by a trustee, such as a corporate trustee or a trusted individual. This ensures that the assets are well managed and generate income while protecting the capital.
6. Blended Family Protection: Testamentary spousal trusts are ideal for families where the testator has children from a previous marriage. The trust can ensure that the spouse is supported, while the assets ultimately pass to the children, avoiding potential conflicts​.
7. Control Over Business Succession: For business owners, a testamentary spousal trust allows the surviving spouse to benefit from the business’s income without disrupting the business’s long-term ownership, which can eventually be passed to the children.
8. Avoidance of the 21-Year Deemed Disposition Rule: Unlike most trusts, testamentary spousal trusts are exempt from the 21-year deemed disposition rule. This rule, which requires most trusts to pay capital gains tax every 21 years, does not apply during the lifetime of the surviving spouse​.

Drawbacks of a Testamentary Spousal Trust

While testamentary spousal trusts provide many benefits, there are some drawbacks:

1. Limited Access to Capital: The spouse has no direct access to the capital of the trust (such as shares or real estate). This means that while they can receive income, they cannot sell or use the assets without the trustee’s approval, which could be restrictive if they need access to larger sums​.
2. Complexity and Costs: The trust requires ongoing management, tax filings, and legal oversight, which can result in ongoing legal, accounting, and administrative fees.
3. Potential Family Conflict: If the surviving spouse and the ultimate beneficiaries (such as children from a previous marriage) have conflicting interests, it could lead to family disputes. Children may want to preserve the capital for inheritance, while the spouse may want higher income​.
4. High Tax Rates for Retained Income: Any income that is not distributed to the spouse is taxed at the highest marginal tax rate within the trust. This could result in a higher tax burden for the trust if income is retained.
5. Trustee Discretion: The trustee controls the assets and makes key decisions about how they are managed. This could lead to disagreements if the trustee’s decisions conflict with the surviving spouse’s needs or preferences.

What Happens If the Spouse Wants to Sell the Shares?

If the assets in the spousal trust are private shares of a family corporation, the spouse does not have the authority to sell the shares directly. The decision to sell assets from the trust lies with the trustee, who must consider whether selling the shares aligns with the purpose of the trust and the long-term interests of both the spouse and future beneficiaries.

If the trustee agrees to sell the shares, this triggers capital gains tax within the trust, and the proceeds from the sale may then be reinvested or distributed according to the terms of the trust. However, selling shares might reduce the capital available for future beneficiaries and could lead to conflict, particularly if the family business is involved.

Conclusion

A testamentary spousal trust is an excellent estate planning tool for those looking to provide for their spouse while safeguarding family assets for future generations. It offers tax benefits, creditor protection, and ensures that assets such as a family business or investments are preserved for children or other heirs. However, it also comes with complexities, including restrictions on access to capital, administrative costs, and potential family conflicts. Careful planning and professional advice are essential to ensure that a testamentary spousal trust is structured properly and meets the family’s needs.

If you think a testamentary spousal trust may be right for your estate plan, it’s important to consult with legal and tax professionals who can help tailor the trust to your unique situation and ensure its long-term success.

Ready to secure your future and protect your loved ones? Book a time to sit down with us and start your estate planning journey today! Visit our calendar to schedule your consultation. We look forward to helping you achieve peace of mind.